Republican Candidates for CD8 Special Election Speak on Border Issues
Thursday, 08 March 2012 21:43The 388 Republican Club hosted a congressional debate Tuesday night at the Voyager RV Resort for the upcoming GOP primary in the Congressional District 8 special election. The April 17, special primary is to name a republican candidate for the June election that will take the place of resigned congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords.
Four candidates have submitted their candidacy including 2010 CD8 republican nominee Jesse Kelly, State Senator Frank Antenori and local broadcaster Dave Sitton. The fourth candidate, former Air Force fighter pilot Martha McSally was not in attendance due to obligations in Washington.
Although issues of the economy and job creation took center stage at the debate, immigration and border security was, as always, a hot topic and all the candidates had their own ideas of ways to curb illegal immigration.
"Build the double layer border fence," said Kelly. "And don't let anybody ever tell you that the most powerful country in the history of the world can't secure their own border."
Kelly said only 5 percent of illegal immigrants crossing the border are caught by Border Patrol and 50 percent of the illegal drugs imported into the United States are done so through the Tucson sector.
When asked about building a more comprehensive fence, Antenori said he didn't think that was necessarily the solution.
"Some places it's just not cost effective, it costs way too much money," said Antenori. "You need a barrier to slow people down but you need boots on the ground to catch those people tripped up by the fence."
"What about those American families who live along the wall, whose ranches have been turned into war zones?" Said Sitton in response.
All three candidates did agree that amnesty is not something they would support.
"If you've come here illegally you have committed a crime, period," said Sitton. "We would not be talking about these issues if we had actually taken care of the border when we needed to."
"You do not give anybody amnesty, because that is rewarding lawbreaking," said Antenori. "They have the opportunity to go home and come back as a legal citizen but we will not reward them for being here illegally."
Antenori did however say that additional programs needed to be installed to curb the need to immigrate illegally.
"Providing a program for seasonal and agricultural workers and in some cases for temporary workers for business we can reduce the demand of people coming here illegally," said Antenori.
Candidates agreed with eachother on many issues including their dislike of President Obama's job perfomance, the Department of Education and tax hikes for higher income families.
Border issues were also almost unilaterally agreed upon, as candidates cited a need for a more comprehensive border fencing and no amnesty of any kind for undocumented citizens in the United States.
"The misconception that the media loves to play is that we're against immigration and that we want to close the border," said Antenori after the debate. "Nobody wants to close the border, we want to control the border and we want commerce to come but we want legal commerce."
The winner of the republican primary will likely face off against Ron Barber, Giffords' district aide and a fellow survivor of last years Jan. 8 Tucson shooting in the special election in June. Barber was shot in the leg and face.
State Rep. Matt Heinz was also running but recently dropped out to endorse Barber for the special election period respecting the wishes of Giffords' camp to finish out her term with somebody on her staff.
The winner in the special election could have a slight leg up in the November election, but with congressional redistricting approved earlier this year, it would be hard to determine a definitive frontrunner.
Much of Congressional District 8 will turn into Congressional District 2 which has slightly different demographics but still includes most of Tucson's east side.
Tuesday's event was the first debate in a series of four scheduled in March, before the primary election April 17. For the candidates full response to illegal immigration reform see the video below.
Video by Lauren Sokol, story written by Brett Haupt
- Streetcar Construction Creates Difficulty for Downtown Businesses
- Take Back the Night: Cover it Live
- Organ Pipe Cactus National Monument clears air about dangers of the border
- Personal activism turns into motivation for demonstration
- Missing on the Border
- University of Arizona NROTC members may carry weapons on training hikes near Mexico
- The Reincarnation Tour: Celebrating a Vibrant and New Central Phoenix
- Rap, Culture & God Lecture
- Cover it Live - CBP's Mario Escalante will share tips of how to be a better border reporter with SPJ.
- Cover it Live: Margaret Regan Talk on Arizona-Mexico Border Stories
- Similarities Emphasized at ‘Queer-ability’ Discussion
- The Essence of Gamma Alpha Omega
- Spanish Heritage Learner Program Enhances UA Education
- Arizona Women's Heritage Trail
- Border Beat Class
- Cover it Live Boxing Training Session
- UA Decathlete Strives to Make the Most of Life in the US
- Ride Report- Premises Park Progress
- The Grip On Tucson Climbing
- Shootout decides 2012 Desert Diamond Cup Championship Game
- Soccer Success Still Kicking in Tucson
- L.A Galaxy v. New York Red Bulls
- La Fiesta de los Vaqueros Tucson Rodeo
Stalk us at:
Border Beat BlogsEducación en la Frontera
By: Shannon Maule
A look at higher education in regard to those who have and have not been able to travel from various countries to the United States. Stories from people in the higher education world relating to the border.A Mosaic America
By: Rachel Kolinski
"Exploring Diversity one Face at a Time"
By: Hope Jamieson
Explore dance throughout the borderlands.A City of Musical Diversity
By: Maria Teracena
Tucson musicians influence and are influenced by the sounds of the world.Culture Crossing
By: Chelsey Barthel
American borders are crossed every day by cultures of all kind. These stories tell the personal experiences of people from different lands, offering further insight into the difference of cultures.
By: Lauren Inouye
A look at Mexican and Latin films that reflect culture, politics, and society -- reviews, research and analysis.
By: Charles Misra
Stories about martial arts and combat sports with a cultural twist, all finding a home in America's southwestern borderlands.Border People
By: Jamie Turow
Profiles of English language learners.
By: Jessica Hoerth
Meet some of the people in Tucson who have made the journey across the border as they share what they came in search of and what struggles they may have encountered along the way.
By: Lauren Urratio
Fashion and how it is impacted by the border and international cultures.
By: Lucy Valencia
News from along the border with MexicoThe Border Project
By: Melissa Guz
"The Border Project" is an art showcase located in the University of Arizona's Museum of Art. It has over 40+ art pieces related to border issues.Athletics and the Border
By: Preston Fawcett
Get to know high school coachs and athletes from Arizona border towns or from Mexico and their struggles to get to where they are.
By: Audrey A. Fitzsimmons
The Southwest boasts of diverse ethnic backgrounds and a wealth of interesting personalities. Border Personalities is dedicated to the people of the Southwest and their stories.
By: Jeff Kessler
U.S. - Mexico border issues, current events, and interesting local storiesMusic of the Border
By: Steven Schiraldi
Music reviews of musical works by Mexican or other ethnic artists.
By: Brett Haupt
A visual exploration of America’s last frontier -- pictures and videos from different areas of the wall and fence that separate two different worlds and insight into what really stands between the United States and Mexico, ramifications of wall building and what it means for the average citizen.Border Athletes
By: Lauren Sokol
Meet international student athletes at the University of Arizona, a look at the recruiting process that helped them find a temporary home in the desert, and culture changes that the athletes might have endured.Journey Across the Border
By: Emily Kjesbo
Spotlighting Mexico’s top travel destinations, as well as a few of its hidden gems.Border Shots
By: Keith Perfetti
A photojournalist looks at how other photographers have viewed the border and shoots lesser known spots of the southwest.
MLS Soccer comes to the Desert
By: Jeff Kessler
All about the 2012 Desert Diamond Cup, a 10 day exhibition soccer tournament featuring four Major League Soccor teams coming to Tucson.